27 October, 2009

No Macarons Here

 macarons
Photos courtesy: Kiris'

 Here for the Daring Bakers challenge? Sorry, but I didn't quite make it through.

This month's challenge was French Macarons - something I’ve wanted to try for a long, long time. My heart would skip a beat when I’d see photos of Macarons at Ladurée or Pierre Hermé. So what if I couldn’t go France, I could surely try and make these at home, couldn’t I? Or so I thought. But that’s just one part of it. For when I did decide to make them a few month ago, I’d hear horror stories about how complex the technique is and how macaron making is almost close to impossible. I wanted to conquer my macaron-making fear, but I knew the one way that I truly would – a Daring Bakers challenge.

So when I learned that Macarons would be the challenge for the month, I was ecstatic. I read the recipe over, decided on my flavor (hazelnut, but of course), did my fair share of research and video watching and set aside an entire Sunday to make macarons – from the very scratch, mind you – right from making the almond+hazelnut flour. I had a good time through this, especially because I was in la-la land dreaming away of the perfect macarons. I really did.

Little did I know things would be drastically different a few hours down the line. Let’s not go on, but instead just snap off the band-aid (mostly for myself) and say it as it is – my macarons didn’t have feet. Flat, limp, lifeless masses of egg, sugar and nuts. A total waste of ingredients - my heart cried.

I'm not sure where I messed up. Did I not whip the egg whites enough? Well, of course I did - I even held the bowl over my head with the egg whites - that's how stiff they were. Did I not use eggs at room temperature? Yes, I did. They sat out overnight just so that I was certain they'd be at room temperature when I'd bake with them. How about leaving the piped macarons to sit on the counter for 30 minutes before baking? Did that too, and not just 30 minutes but a good 3 hours.

Now, I can either wonder what went wrong or strive to make these again. I'm going to chose option number two. I didn't have time to give these a second shot. But I sure as hell am, and will look to Tartelette for inspiration (who else?!).

Before I stop rambling, you have got to see this adorable artwork! These aren't macarons but they are made of clay! And the entire box is smaller than a matchstick. Don't believe me? Check this photo: I've never seen human fingers look this gigantic.

fake macarons
Photo courtesy:PetitPlat by SK

The 2009 October Daring Bakers’ challenge was brought to us by Ami S. She chose macarons from Claudia Fleming’s The Last Course: The Desserts of Gramercy Tavern as the challenge recipe.

Stumble Upon Toolbar

21 comments:

  • MeetaK

    oh shaheen sorry to hear this. i believe from reading your post there might be two things that maybe had an effect on the outcome. maybe you whipped the eggs far too much and that they sat out to dry to long. i read somewhere 30 to 60 mins is usually the max.
    but seriously i hope you do not give up and try to make them again.
    hugs for trying!

  • The Purple Foodie

    Whoops! is that so? A friend of mine studying at Le Cordon Bleu Paris told me to let it sit for 5 hours! And I always live in the fear of over whipping. Thanks, Meeta. You're awesome.

  • Danielle

    Sorry to hear about your macaron episode, I haven't quite recovered from mine to revisit this. Did you use the French or the Italian method for these macarons? I've heard that the French method is a little more tricky, but the Italian method, which uses a meringue base, is more stable.

  • alice

    I had major DB fail too. I'm just letting it go and hope for better next month!

  • pigpigscorner

    sorry to hear that, macarons are rather fickle I have to say.

  • Disha

    Hey S! Sorry abt ur macarons! Don't give up! I'm sure ur next time will be great!

  • Amy I.

    My experience with the challenge recipe sounds the same as yours. I'm sorry that it was such a letdown, and I hope you have better luck with Helen's recipe! I tried hers twice and (almost) got it right. Can't wait to see what yours look like when you get it to work; I know it'll be very soon!

  • arjwiz

    All in all, im sure it was a good experience. you've explained it well in your post!

  • Y

    What a shame! Seems like quite a few people did not have much success with the given recipe.

  • Tracy @ Sugarcrafter

    I couldn't get the recipe to work for me, either. Oh well, there's always next month, right?

  • bethany (Dirty Kitchen Secrets)

    Oh Shaheen sorry to hear about this :( I'm going in for the next DB! So nervous!!! kisses x

  • Anonymous

    Sounds like the whites were over whipped. In my experience, and the way I was taught at the CIA, whites should only go to soft peaks. If you tried to hold them over your head you would have egg on your head! Try try try again!

  • Angie

    I have been wanting to try macarons too! But I am also afraid! I always mess up the first batch of anything, especially baked goods, can't follow directions to save my life! If I have my hubby to help, though, he can keep me on track. I hope you try these again, I know you'll get it, you are so talented!

  • Mimi

    Sorry about your macaroons. I used Syrup & Tang's method, all based on weight ratios of ingredients, which worked well for me. Don't give up.
    Mimi

  • Helen @ World Foodie Guide

    Ah, macarons! I made these along with a group of other food bloggers under the expert tuition of a chef at L'atelier des Chefs in London almost one year ago. It was most enjoyable and I can confirm that they are tricky to make! When you laid them out on the tray, did you lift it up and let it drop onto the counter several times? This is really important apparently...

  • Jen @ My Kitchen Addiction

    Sorry your macs didn't turn out... Mine didn't either. I plan on trying them again, though. We'll see :)

  • Katie

    Oh no! I've heard that macarons are VERY hard to make. I've only tried a macaron once and that was in France and it was delicious!

    You should try again! :)

  • The Purple Foodie

    So turns out a lot of people had the same problem. It's not me, it's the recipe. Time to rejoice!!! I love you guys. :D

    Aww Danielle, thank you for the twitter hugs. :)) I used the French method - the next two recipes I'm going to try are going to be from Helen and David Lebovitz.

    Alice: Thank you for the moral support - looks like the recipe didn't work for many people so I'm not going to worry too much about it. :)

    Pigpigscorner: That helps. ;)

    Disha: Yes, because we will bake them together!

    Amy I: Sucks that they didn't work out for you either, but glad to know I'm not alone.

    Y: Your stuff is stunning Y! Good thing you were on autopilot mode. ;)

    Tracy: I'm glad we at least made the attempt!

    Bethany: Oh AWESEOME news! Don't be nervous - the group is made of some amazing, amazing people!

    Anon: I always live in fear of over whipping! oh well, next time!

    Angie: Thank you for the wonderful compliment. All the best with your attempt.

    Mimi: I will look up that method. Thanks.

    Helen: I certainly didn't do that. Will keep in mind for next time. But won't that make the macaron spread on the sheet more than it's supposed to? Novice here.:)

    Jen: Thanks and all the best with your next attempt!

    Katie: Now I yearn to go to France. Again. Thanks for the encouragement!

  • Anushruti

    I admire your courage and forthrightness. We all have our ups and down in the kitchen but everyone Everyone talks only about their success and here we have you talking about your not very successful attempt! Way to go girl!

  • Ingrid

    Sorry about that .....next time you'll get 'em!
    ~ingrid

  • lavienouveau

    I've made macaroons before but I had the same exact problem with this recipe too! its cursed I tell you - cursed!

Post a Comment

Thank you for your comment! Glad to have you over :)